Reasoning and Reflection Regarding Issues of Faith: a Comparison between the Views of Allamah Tabatabai and Gabriel Marcel

Assaran Qommi, Hossein; Dirbaz, Asgar

doi:10.22091/pfk.2017.1185.1419

Reasoning and Reflection Regarding Issues of Faith: a Comparison between the Views of Allamah Tabatabai and Gabriel Marcel

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

¹ PhD candidate, Comparative Philosophy, Allamah Tabatabaii University, Tehran, Iran

² Associate Professor, Department of Islamic Philosophy and Theology, University of Qom, Iran

10.22091/pfk.2017.1185.1419

Abstract

In this article we strive to study the position of intellection and thinking in belief-related issues according to Alamah Tabatabai and Gabriel Marcel. The position and function of the intellect in belief-related issues has always been a point of focus of intellectuals and philosophers and has had a decisive role in determining the path of theology. Allamah Tabatabai and Marcel have also given special attention to belief-related issues and intellection and its position regarding these issues. Marcel criticizes the type of intellection regarding belief-related issues when encountering the complexity of these issues and presents a new way of thinking which is specific and personal and is instrumental in understanding belief-related realities. According to Marcel, there is an essential difference between belief-related issues and logical issues and abstract thinking is particular to logical issues; but Allamah presents the domain of this thinking to be much more extensive by considering the intellect to be independent in understanding realities, so that belief-related thinking comes under intellectual thinking. He considers the position of intellect to be very high by considering the authority of the intellect to be essential and definitive and in contrast to Marcel, he believes that the difference between religious denomination and philosophy is a method and they both seek a shared goal which is understanding realities. The path followed in this article is to first explain the views of both philosophers regarding the topic and then comparing them with each other.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Anderson, T. C. (2006). Commentary on Gabriel Marcel's The Mystery of Being. United States: Marquette University Press.

- Baiju, Nt. (2006). InterSubjectivity ۔ A Treatise on the Philosophy of Gabriel Marcel. Scribd.

https://www.scribd com/doc/82100649/Inter۔Subjectivity۔A۔Treatise۔on۔the۔Philosophy۔of۔Gabriel۔Marcel.

- Hernandez, J. G. (2011). Gabriel Marcel's Ethics of Hope Evil, God and Virtue. New York: Continuum International Publishing Group.

- Macquarrie, J. (1972). existentialism. New York: Penguin Books Ltd.

- Marcel, G. (1949). Being and Having. (translated by: Kathatine Farrer). England: Dacre Press Westminster.

- Marcel, G. (1950). Mystery of Being I. Reflection and Mystery, Illinois Chicago: Henry Regnery Company.

- Sweetman, B. (2006). Marcel on God and Religious Experience, and the Critique of Alston and Hick. American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly, 80 (3) , 407۔420‌‌.

- Existentialism. (n.d.). In Wikipedia. Retrieved March 31, 2017, from https://en‌‌.wikipedia.org/wiki/Existentialism.

References in Arabic / Persian

- Afshar Karimi, A. (1384 SH). ‘Aql, Ma‘refat va Manteq az Manzar Allama Tabatabai (the intellect knowledge and logic according to Allamah Tabatabai). Pazhouhesh Dini. Vol. 11, p. 117-136.

- Alya, M. (1387 SH). Tamayuz-i Mas’ale va Raz dar Andishe-i Marcel (the distinction between issue and secret in Marcel’s thought). Philosophy. Vol. 8, p. 93-108.

- Beheshtipur, R. (2011). Intellect and Revelation from Allameh Tabatabaei’s Point of View. Philosophy of Religion. Vol. 8, issue 9, spring 2011, p. 5-24.

- Blackham, H. J. (1368 SH). Six Existential Thinkers. Translated into Persian by: Mohsen Hakimi, as: Shish Mutafakker-i Existansialist. Tehran: Markaz Publications.

- Eslami, H. (1384 SH). Tabatabai va Defa‘ az Manzelat-i ‘Aql (Tabatabai and defending the position of the intellect). Pazhouhesh Dini. Vol. 11, p. 93-116.

- Hoseinzade, M. (1386 SH). ‘Aql az Manzar-i Ma‘refat Shenasi (the intellevct according to epistemology). Marifat-i Falsafi. Issue 16, p. 11-60.

http://www.binesheno.com/Files/books.php?idVeiw=1972&level=2&subid=1972.

- Yip, Hing Wah. (1384 SH). Ricoeur va Matarak-i Marcel (Muqaddame-i bar Tafsir-i Ricoeur az Marcel) (Ricoeur and Marcel’s legacy, an introduction to Ricoeur’s explanation of Marcel). Translated by: Majid Kamali. Kheradname-yi Hamshahri. Vol. 1, p. 29-31.

- Keen, S. (1381 SH). Gabriel Marcel. Translated by: Mustafa Malekian. Tehran: Negah-i Mu‘asir Publications.

- Khademi, E; Arabi, A. (2012). A Comparative Study of Allameh Majlesi's and Allameh Tabataba'i's Views on the Nature and Functions of Reason. Hekmat va Falsafe (Wisdom and Philosophy). Vol. 8, issue 30, summer 2012, p. 69-92.

- Majlisi, M.B. (1403 AH). Bihar al-Anwar al-Jame‘ah li Durar Akhbar al-A’immat al-At-har (a book of narrations). Edited by: a group of scholars. Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-‘Arabi.

- Marcel, G. (1381 SH). The Philosophy of Existentialism. Translated into Persian by: Shahla Eslami, as: Falsafe-i Existansialism. Tehran: Negah-i Mu‘asir Publications.

- Marcel, G. (1388 SH). Problematic Man. Translated into Persian by: Beta Shamsini, as: Insan-i Mas’ale gun. Tehran: Qoqnus.

- Marcel, G. (1391 SH). Ta’ammulati dar Bab-i Iman (reflections regarding faith). Translated into Persian by: Rohullah Alizade.Ettelat Hekmat va Marefat. Vol. 9, p. 55-60.

- Marcel, G. (1392 SH). Being and Having. Translated into Persian by: Seddiqa Farahani, as: Busan va Dashtan. Tehran: Parseh Books.

- Muin, M. (1381 SH). Farhang-i Muin (an Arabic dictionary). Tehran: Adina.

Rahimpour, F. (1391 SH). Vaseteha-i Sheknakht az Didgah-i Allamah Tabatabi (the mediators of cognition according to Allamah Tabatabi). The Quarterly of Kheradname-yi Sadra. No. 70, p. 67-84.

Razavi, M. (1389 SH). Naqdha-i Allamah Tabatabai bar Allamah Majlisi (Allamah Tabatabai’s critiques on Allamah Majlisi (annotation on Bihar al-Anwar), from the site:

- Shakirin, H.R. (1391 SH). Karkerd-i ‘Aql dar Fahm-i Din (the function of the intellect in understanding religion). Qabasat. Issue 65, p. 5-26.

- Shir Aliyuf, B; Qayyumi, M.B. (2011). A Glance at Allama Tabatabai and St. Augustine’s Views on Faith and Reason. Pazhuhesh Name Hikmat va Falsafe Islami. Issue 34, p. 23-42.

- Tabatabai, M.H. (1374 SH). Tarjume-i Tafsi al-Mizan (a translation of Tabatabai’s al-Mizan). Translated by: Muhammad Baqir Musavi Hamedani. Qom: Daftar-i Intisharat Islami.

- Tabatabai, M.H. (1385 SH). Nihayat al-Hikmah. Edition and annotation by: Gholam Reza Fayyazi. Qom: Markaz-i Intisharat-i Mu’assasa-i Amozeshi Pazhouheshi-i Imam Khoemini.

- Tabatabai, M.H. (1387 SH) Shi‘e: Majmu‘a Muzakerat ba Profesor Henry Corbin (Shi‘a: a collection of discussion with Prof. Henry Corbin). Compiled by: Hadi Khosroshahi. Qom: Mu’assasa-i Bustan-i Ketab.

- Tabatabai, M.H. (1388 SH). Ali va Falsafe-i Ilahi (Ali and Divine philosophy). Qom: Daftar-i Intisharat Islami.

- Tabatabai, M.H. (1388 SH). Shi‘e dar Islam (Shi‘a in Islam) (new print). Qom: Daftar-i Intisharat Islami.

- Tabatabai, M.H. (1402 AH). Al-Mizan fi Tafsir al-Qur’an (a commentary of the Koran). Qom: Esmailian.