An Analysis of Motahhari and Brümmer’s Response to the Issue of God’s Mediation and Benevolence

Jarrahi, Um Hani; Akbari, Reza

doi:10.22091/pfk.2019.2819.1812

An Analysis of Motahhari and Brümmer’s Response to the Issue of God’s Mediation and Benevolence

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Um Hani Jarrahi ¹
Reza Akbari ²

¹ PhD candidate of philosophy of religion and modern theology, Islamic Azad University, science and research branch, Tehran, iran

² Professor, imam Sadiq university, faculty of theology, islamic teachings and guidance, Department of islamic philosophy and Kalam, Tehran, iran

10.22091/pfk.2019.2819.1812

Abstract

Abstract
The teaching of mediation in Islamic tradition refers to a person requesting forgiveness of another and in the Christian tradition apart from forgiveness includes the bestowal of goodness to another as well. Motahhari and Brümmer consider the acceptance of mediation to be faced with the problem of superiority of the mediator’s mercy as compared to God’s mercy and the limitedness of God’s benevolence. Motahhari believes the answer to this problem to be in the attention to the hierarchy in the world’s system and the bestowal of good to creation in the form of a linear system; mediation is not the existential cause for forgiveness but rather the preparatory cause for the bestowal of forgiveness from God. As a reply to this problem, Brümmer addresses God’s permission for man’s participation in spreading good to others in the form of prayers. According to Brümmer, God has made the world such that through prayers – while establishing a loving relationship with God – man can also have an active participation with God’s power in the acceptance of prayer. In this way, Motahhari and Brümmer with their answers consider mediation and God’s absolute benevolence to be consistent with one another. According to both, the world has an order in which man can play a role in spreading good to others with God’s permission.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

- Austin, M. R. (1978). Can Intercessory Prayer Work?. Expository Times.(89), 335۔339.

- Bertocci, P. A. (1951). Introduction to Philosophy of Religion. Englewood Cliffs NJ.

- Brummer, V. (1984). What are We Doing When We Pray?. London: SCM Press LTD.

- Brummer, V. (1993). The Model of Love. Cambridge.

- Jarrahi, o; Kashfi, A. (2016). The Impact of Prayer on the Orderly Cosmos. Philosophy of Religion Research. 1(14),47-68.

- Stump, E. (1979). Petitionary Prayer. American Philosophical Quarterly. 2 (16), 81-91.

References in Arabic / Persian

- Brümmer, V. (1392 SH). What are we doing when we pray? a Philosophical Inquiry. Translated into Persian by: Ashkan Bohrani and Masoud Rahbari with annotations by Qasem Kakai, as: Hengam-i Neyayesh che Mikunim? Dar Bab-i Neyayyish va Seresht-i Iman (what are we doing when we pray; concerning paryer and the nature of faith). Tehran: Hermes.

- Gharavian, M. (1371 SH). Shafa‘at az Didgah-i ‘Aql va Naql (mediation from the perspective of intellect and narrations). Nour-i Ilm Journal. No. 46, pp. 29-55.

- Ibn Abil Hadid, A. H. (1404 AH). Sharh-i Nahjul Balagha li Ibn Abil Hadid (a commentary of the Nahjul Balagha by Ibn Abil Hadid). Qom: Ayatollah Mar‘ashi Najafi Library.

- Jamshedi Hasanabadi, J. (1394 SH). Barresi-i Shubuhat-i Mas’ale-i Shafa‘at ba tikye bar Ara’-i Allameh Tabatabai (a study of the doubts regarding the issue of mediation based on Allamah Tabatabai’s views). Kowsar Journal. 54,157-187.

- Jarrahi, U. H; Kashfi, A. R. (1395 SH). The Impact of Prayer on the Orderly Cosmos: A Comparative study of Mortaza Mutahhari and Eleonore Stump. Philosophy of Religion Research (Namah-i Hikmat). 14,(1)1, 47-68.

- Makarem Shirazi, N. (1384 SH). Barguzide-i Tafsir-i Namooneh (a selection from the commentary of Namooneh). Research and compilation by: Ahmad Ali Babai. Vol. 4. Tehran: Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyyah. 15^th ed.

- Motahhari, M. (1391 SH). Adl-i Elahi (Divine Justice). From the electronic version of the complete works of Motahhari. Qom: Computer Research Center of Islamic Sciences. Sadra Publixations.

- Motahhari, M. (1391 SH). Ashenayi ba Qor’an 11 (an introduction to the Qoran). From the electronic version of the complete works of Motahhari. Qom: Computer Research Center of Islamic Sciences. Sadra Publixations.

- Motahhari, M. (1391 SH). Ashenayi ba Qor’an 5 (an introduction to the Qoran). From the electronic version of the complete works of Motahhari. Qom: Computer Research Center of Islamic Sciences. Sadra Publixations.

- Tabatabai, M. H. (1366). Tafsir al-Mizan (a Qoranic commentary). Translated by: Muhammad Baer Musavi Hamedani. Vol. 17. Tehran: Bunyad-i ‘Ilmi va Fikri-i Allameh Tabatabai. 2^nd ed.