An Analysis of Al-Kindi's View of Human Perfection

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Professor of Philosophy and Theology, Shahid RajaeeTeacher Training University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Perfection is an anthropological issue that is inherently human in nature, but in theory, Greek philosophers played a prominent role. They pursued this more as a virtue. The main question of this research is what analysis can be provided for Al-Kindi’s view of human perfection? This research was done using a descriptive-analytic method and its most important findings are: In analyzing the Al-Kindi’s view of perfection, we can divide it into two types – philosophical perfection and moral perfection. Philosophical perfection in this research means perfection in the field of theoretical reason. In his treatise on reason, he used it in four meanings, the second meaning of which refers to the reason considered in this research. Although he uses a degree of theoretical reason, we see a kind of ambiguity and weaknesses in his philosophical perfection.
What we mean by moral perfection in this research is the perfection of the practical intellect, which is called virtue. He is more morally influenced by Plato than Aristotle. And according to the powers of the human soul, it divides virtues into four parts – wisdom, prudence or courage, chastity, and justice. To explain further, a human being has many virtues, and human virtues refer to the same desirable human creation which is divided into two types, one of which is in the soul and the other surrounds the human body and is one of the effects in the soul. The kind that exists in the soul is divided into three types: wisdom, chastity and the one that surrounds the human body and one of the effects of this thing in the soul is justice. When a necessity arises, one does not fear death and repels something that is against his will; chastity is eating things to train the body and maintaining it after all. Virtues have two extremes and each of these two is a departure from moderation and vice. The soul is a slowly transcending light and after separating from the body, it becomes aware of everything in the world and no secret is hidden from it.
In this article, an attempt has been made to solve the problem of perfection from Al-Kindi’s point of view using a rational-descriptive method. The important point about Al-Kindi is that he was in the early stages of the translation movement and was not familiar enough with Greek works. Also, according to the available reports, not all of his works have reached us so it is difficult to judge definitively about his views on various issues, including perfection. However, from Al-Kindi’s point of view, perfection can be divided into philosophical and moral perfection but for the aforementioned reasons, both types of perfection are ambiguous and there seems to be more of an ambiguity regarding philosophical perfection in his works.
 

Keywords


Abu Reida, M. A. H. (1950). Rasaʾil al-Kindi al-Falsafiyya [Kindi’s philosophical treatises]. N.p.
Al-Fakhouri, H. & Al-Jarr, K. (1358 AP/1979-80). Tarikh-i Falsafe dar Jahan-i Islami [the history of philosophy in the Ilamic world]. (Ayuq, A. H., Trans.). Tehran: Zaman Books. [In Persian].
Al-Kindi, Y. (1387 AP/2008-9).Majmuʿa –yi Rasaʾil-i Falsafi-yi al-Kindi [a collections of al-Kindi’s philosophical treatises]. (Thani, M. Y., Trans.). Tehran: Ilmi va Farhangi Publictions. [In Persian].
Al-Kindi, Y. (1950a). Rasaʾil al-Kindi al-Falsafiyya: Risalat al-Kindi fi Hudud al-Ashyaʾ wa Rusumiha, vol. 1 [one of al-Kindi’s philosophical treatises] (analytic foreword by Muhammad Abdul Hadi Abu Reida). Egypt: Dar al-Fikr al-Arabi.
Al-Kindi, Y. (1950b). Rasaʾil al-Kindi al-Falsafiyya: Kitab al-Kindi ila al-Muʿtasim billah fi al-Falsafat al-Ula [one of al-Kindi’s philosophical treatises] (analytic foreword by Muhammad Abdul Hadi Abu Reida). Egypt: Dar al-Fikr al-Arabi.
Al-Kindi, Y. (1950c).Rasaʾil al-Kindi al-Falsafiyya: al-Qawl fi an-Nafs; al-Mukhtasar min Kitab Arastu, Falatun, wa Saʾir al-Falasafa [one of al-Kindi’s philosophical treatises] (analytic foreword by Muhammad Abdul Hadi Abu Reida). Egypt: Dar al-Fikr al-Arabi.
Al-Kindi, Y. (1950d).Rasaʾil al-Kindi al-Falsafiyya: Risalat al-Kindi fi al-Inabah ʿan Sujud al-Jurm al-Aqsa [one of al-Kindi’s philosophical treatises] (analytic foreword by Muhammad Abdul Hadi Abu Reida). Egypt: Dar al-Fikr al-Arabi.
Al-Kindi, Y. (1950e).Rasaʾil al-Kindi al-Falsafiyya: Kitab al-Jawahir al-Khamsah, vol. 2 [one of al-Kindi’s philosophical treatises] (analytic foreword by Muhammad Abdul Hadi Abu Reida). Egypt: Dar al-Fikr al-Arabi.
Al-Kindi, Y. (1950f).Rasaʾil al-Kindi al-Falsafiyya: fi annahu (tujad) Jawahir al-Ajsam, vol. 1 [one of al-Kindi’s philosophical treatises] (analytic foreword by Muhammad Abdul Hadi Abu Reida). Egypt: Dar al-Fikr al-Arabi.
Al-Kindi, Y. (1950g).Rasaʾil al-Kindi al-Falsafiyya: Risalat Abi Yusuf Yaʿqoub b. Ishaq al-Kindi fi al-ʿAql, vol. 1 [one of al-Kindi’s philosophical treatises] (analytic foreword by Muhammad Abdul Hadi Abu Reida). Egypt: Dar al-Fikr al-Arabi.
Al-Kindi, Y. (1950h).Rasaʾil al-Kindi al-Falsafiyya: Risalat al-Kindi fi Mahiyyat al-Nowm wa al-Ruʾya, vol. 1[one of al-Kindi’s philosophical treatises] (analytic foreword by Muhammad Abdul Hadi Abu Reida). Egypt: Dar al-Fikr al-Arabi.
Aristotle. (1378 AP/1999-2000). Akhlaq-I Nikhumakhos [Nichomachean Ethics]. (Lutfi, M. H., Trans.). Tehran: Tarh-i No. [In Persian].
Avicenna (Ibn Sina). (1364 AP/1985-6). Al-Najat min al-Gharq fi Bahr al-Dalalaat [The Book of Salvation]. N.p.
Avicenna (Ibn Sina). (1403 AH). Al-Isharat wa al-Tanbihat [Remarks and Admonitions] (2nd ed.). Tehran: Al-Ketab Publications.
Copleston, F. C. (1362 AP/1983-4). Tarikh-i Falsafe [The History of Philosophy], vol. 1. (Mujtabawi, J. D., Trans.). Tehran: Ilmi va Farhangi Publication Center. [In Persian].
Davudi, A. M. (1349 AP/1970-1). ʿAql da Hekmat-i Mashaʾ az Arastu ta Ibn Sina [the intellect in Peripatetic Philosophy from Aristotle to Avicenna]. Tehran: Dehkhoda Bookstore.
Javadi, M. (n.d.). Musahebeye Akhlaq-i Fazilat dar Dore-yi Yunan Bastan va Taʾthiratish ba Akhlaq-i Islami [interviewing virtue ethics in ancient Greece and its effects of Islamic ethics]. N.p.
Khazaie, Z. (1389 AP/2010-1). Akhlaq-i Fazilat (virtue ethics). Tehran: Hekmat Publications.
McIntyre, A. (1379 AP/2000-1). Tarikhche-yi Falsafe-yi Akhlaq [A Short History of Ethics]. (Rahmati, I., Trans.). Tehran: Hekmat Publications. [In Persian].
Mesbah Yazdi, M. T. (1376 AP/1997-8). Khodshenasi baraye Khodsazi [self-knowledge for sel-refinement]. Qom: Imam Khomeini Education and Research Institute (ra).
Pincoffs, E. (1382 AP/2003-4). Az Masʾale Mevari ta Fazilatgerayi [Quandaries and Virtues: Against Reductivism in Ethics]. (Hasani, H. R. & Alipour, M., Trans. and commentary). Qom: Maaref Publications. [In Persian].
Plato. (1380 AP/2001-2). Majmuʿa-yi Athaar-i Aflatoon [a collection of Plato’s works] (3rd ed.). (Lutfi, M. H., Trans.). Tehran: Khwarazmi Publications. [In Persian].
Qanbari, B. (1388 AP/2009-10). Darbare-yi Ketab: Rah-i Kamal [about the book: the path of perfection]. Ketab Mah-e-Din. 148(13), 34-44.
Soltanalgharai, K. & Mesrabadi, J. (2007). A Comparative Study of the Viewpoint of Islam and Carl Rogers on Human Nature and Perfection. Bi-quarterly Journal of Islamic Education. 2(4), 41-61. Retrieved: May 27, 2021, from https://www.cgie.org.ir/fa/news/26679/
CAPTCHA Image